Prime Minister Justin Trudeau meets with Mark Carney at the G20 Summit in Buenos Aires, Argentina, Nov. 30, 2018. (THE CANADIAN PRESS/Sean Kilpatrick)

By Canadian Press

US-Canada Relations

Trudeau, Carney push back over Trump’s ongoing 51st state comments

Dec 28, 2024 | 12:42 PM

Two senior members of the federal cabinet were in Florida Friday pushing Canada’s new $1.3 billion border plan with members of Donald Trump’s transition team, a day after Prime Minister Justin Trudeau himself appeared to finally push back at the president-elect over his social media posts about turning Canada into the 51st state.

Finance Minister Dominic LeBlanc and Foreign Affair Minister Melanie Joly shared few details of their meetings in Palm Beach, simply saying in a statement the U.S. officials they met with took notes and agreed to relay messages to Trump.

“Minister LeBlanc and Minister Joly had a positive, productive meeting at Mar-a-Lago with Howard Lutnick and Doug Burgum, as a followup to the dinner between the prime minister and President Trump last month,” wrote Jean-Sebastien Comeau, a spokesman for LeBlanc.

Lutnick is Trump’s nominee for commerce secretary, and Burgum is the former governor of North Dakota and current nominee for secretary of the interior. When announcing Lutnick as his commerce pick Trump said the chief executive of the financial firm Cantor Fitzgerald would be in charge of the Trump “tariff and trade agenda.”

“Both Ministers outlined the measures in Canada’s Border Plan and reiterated the shared commitment to strengthen border security as well as combat the harm caused by fentanyl to save Canadian and American lives.”

New beginnings

Humboldt Broncos bus crash survivor embarks on coaching career in Prince Albert

Dec 26, 2024

rivals turned linemates

Boychuk and Meunier's shared history continues with Raiders

Dec 26, 2024

Year in Review

From the ice to the court: P.A.'s top sports stories of 2024

Dec 25, 2024

He added the ministers agreed to continue the discussions in the coming weeks.

Joly is also expected to meet in Florida with senator Lindsay Graham Friday evening.

Minister of Foreign Affairs Melanie Joly, centre, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, right, and Dominic LeBlanc participate in a news conference in Ottawa, Oct. 14, 2024. (Justin Tang/The Canadian Press)

This trip comes less than four weeks before Trump is sworn in again as president. He has threatened to impose a new 25 per cent import tariff on Canada and Mexico the same day over concerns about a trade imbalance, as well as illegal drugs and migration issues at the borders.

The broad strokes of Canada’s new border plan were made public Dec. 17, including a new aerial intelligence task force to provide round-the-clock surveillance of the border, and improved efforts using technology and canine teams to seek out drugs in shipments leaving Canada.

Comeau said earlier Friday morning the ministers would also emphasize the negative impacts of Trump’s threatened tariffs on both Canada and the U.S.

Comeau said the ministers were to build on the discussions that took place last month when Trudeau and LeBlanc met Trump at Mar-a-Lago just days after Trump first made his tariff threat.

It was at that dinner on Nov. 29 when Trump first raised the notion of Canada becoming the 51st state, a comment LeBlanc has repeatedly since insisted was just a joke.

But Trump has continued the quip repeatedly in various social media posts, including in his Christmas Day message when he said Canadians would pay lower taxes and have better military protection if they became Americans.

He has taken to calling Trudeau “governor” instead of prime minister.

It isn’t clear if LeBlanc raised the issue with Trump’s team in Palm Beach Friday.

Trudeau had not directly responded to any of the jabs, but on Thursday posted a link to a six-minute long video on YouTube from 2010 in which American journalist Tom Brokaw “explains Canada to Americans.”

“Some information about Canada for Americans” was all he wrote in the post.

The video, which originally aired during the 2010 Vancouver Olympics, explains similarities between the two countries, including their founding based on immigration, their trading relationship and the actions of the Canadian Army in World War 2 and other modern conflicts.

“In the long history of sovereign neighbours there has never been a relationship as close, productive and peaceful as the U.S. and Canada,” Brokaw says in the video.

Former Bank of Canada governor Mark Carney, who is at the centre of some of Trudeau’s recent domestic political troubles, also called out Trump’s antics on X Thursday, calling it “casual disrespect” and “carrying the ‘joke’ too far.”

“Time to call it out, stand up for Canada, and build a true North American partnership,” said Carney, who Trudeau was courting to join his cabinet before Chrystia Freeland resigned as finance minister last week.

Freeland’s sudden departure, three days after Trudeau informed her he would be firing her as finance minister in favour of Carney, left Trudeau’s leadership even more bruised than it already was.

Despite the expectation Carney would assume the role, he did not and has not made any statements about it. LeBlanc was sworn in as finance minister instead the same day Freeland quit.

More than two dozen Liberal MPs have publicly called on Trudeau to resign as leader, and Trudeau is said to be taking the holidays to think about his next steps.

He is currently vacationing in British Columbia. He did not make a public statement about the meeting as of publication.