Click here to sign up for our free daily newsletter.

Saskatoon judge sentences woman for death of teens

Jun 12, 2015 | 5:07 PM

A woman who was drunk behind the wheel of a stolen truck when she killed two teenagers was sentenced Friday in Saskatoon Court of Queen’s Bench.

Cheyann Crystal Peeteetuce pleaded guilty to seven charges stemming from the May 2014 incident, including two counts of criminal negligence causing the deaths of J.P. Haughey and Sarah Wensley, both 17.

Justice Ted Zarzeczny pointed to Peeteetuce’s aboriginal heritage and a lengthy history of abuse and neglect in handing down a total sentence of six years. He also noted that Peeteetuce’s grandparents were residential school survivors and that this likely contributed to the dysfunction in her own upbringing.

Quoting from reports commissioned ahead of sentencing, Zarzeczny revealed that Peeteetuce grew up in an abusive home with an alcoholic and often absent mother. The young Peeteetuce witnessed numerous acts of domestic violence by her stepfather, and was beaten several times herself. At one point, her stepfather reportedly tried to drown her.

The reports noted Peeteetuce left school in Grade 9 while pregnant with her daughter. After the child’s birth, she descended further into substance abuse and prostitution. She joined the Indian Posse street gang for protection after being swarmed and stabbed by members of the rival Native Syndicate. Peeteetuce had another child, a son, who died while still an infant. The child was in the care of his father when he died of a drug overdose.

The Crown had asked for a sentence of 12 years for Peeteetuce’s crimes. The families of the two dead teens reacted with shock as Zarzeczny delivered his decision.

Haughey’s father couldn’t restrain an outburst, calling out: ‘That’s ridiculous, your honour’ as Zarzeczny was still reading.

Haughey’s mother was devastated. Sobbing uncontrollably, she screamed “karma will strike you down!” as Peeteetuce was led from the courtroom in leg irons and handcuffs. As the rest of the gallery filed out, she was heard screaming “you killed us again” repeatedly.

With 20 months credit for the time on remand, Peeteetuce has four years and four months left on her sentence. Zarzeczny issued a recommendation that part of that time be served at a healing lodge in Maple Creek.

Speaking outside the courtroom, Wensley’s father David said he was appalled with the decision, he also voiced outrage at the decision not to try a 17-year-old passenger in the stolen truck as an adult.

“Four years, four months to serve, she’s going to be out on parole in two-thirds of that. And some of that time spent at a health and wellness centre down in Maple Creek? That’s our justice system? These girls, they’re Indian Posse gang members,” he said.

Wensley also had harsh words for the Saskatoon Tribal Council, which sent representatives to the 17-year-old’s court proceedings.

“With the Saskatoon Trival Council, that would be like one of our (city) council members going to a Hells Angel’s trial and representing, supporting the Hells Angel. What’s really the difference?” he asked.

Valerie Harvey, Peeteetuce’s lawyer, explained that her client had pushed to plead guilty since her first appearance in court. Harvey said she actually had to slow the process down to make sure that the case against her client was supported by the evidence before proceeding with the plea.  Harvey read a statement from her client to reporters. In the brief letter, Peeteetuce apologized to the victim’s families, as well as to her own family and community.

In addition to the prison term, Zarzeczny also imposed a 20-year driving ban on Peeteetuce.

panews@jpbg.ca

On Twitter: @BrynLevy