Immunity conferred in many ways and sometimes not at all

September 7, 2017 - 9:00am

DEAR DR. ROACH: I am confused about immunity from vaccines versus immunity gained from getting a disease. Protection from whooping cough can wane in as little as four years (both disease and vaccine), but the tetanus vaccine can last up to 30 years. However, the disease gives no natural immunity. And measles disease gives lifelong immunity. What causes the differences? -- C.B.B.

ANSWER: Some diseases are able to escape the body's defense systems. The immune system works better if it has "seen" a germ (virus, bacteria, parasite or fungus) before. Unfortunately, there are diseases to which the body never gains immunity. Although there are exceptions, in general, diseases that give lifelong immunity are easier to make vaccines for. Take measles, for example. You are right that most people will have lifelong immunity after two doses of vaccine or after having the disease. (There are serious complications of the disease, which is why it's much better to get the vaccine.) However, most people will never get natural immunity from malaria, even after heavy exposure and numerous bouts of the disease.

Some diseases, like influenza, are constantly changing, requiring new vaccines every year. It's a challenge for immunologists to create effective vaccines, but researchers continue to make progress.

In the case of pertussis (whooping cough), infection does not prevent recurrences. In the pre-vaccine era, nearly everyone had pertussis as a child, and it is estimated that an adult had pertussis between two and three times in a lifetime. Also in the pre-vaccine era, there were about 9,000 deaths per year from pertussis, compared with about 20 deaths per year now. Even though immunity from the current pertussis vaccine does wane, booster doses are not currently recommended.

In the case of tetanus, surviving the infection (even now, 10 to 20 percent of those infected with tetanus die) does not confer immunity. Survivors should be immunized as soon as the condition stabilizes. A full series of tetanus vaccines gives nearly 100 percent protection, which is why tetanus is called "the unforgivable disease": Nobody should get it, and if the omission of the vaccine was the physician's fault, he or she can't be forgiven for it.

The mechanisms by which infections escape our immune system are complicated: Over millions of years, humans have evolved to be better at fighting off infections, but infections have been learning to evade our defenses.

DEAR DR. ROACH: In a recent column, you said that "current or former smokers should not take the standard supplement, as it contains beta carotene, which may increase lung cancer risk." By "standard supplement," are you referring to AREDS? Also, I have never heard that smokers or former smokers should not take beta carotene. Why? I have not smoked in over 30 years. Would this affect me? -- V.W.

ANSWER: Two large studies showed the benefit of vitamin supplementation in slowing the progression of macular degeneration. The first one, the AREDS, used a combination of vitamins, including beta carotene. The second, AREDS2, did not.

A different study, designed to determine whether vitamin supplements help to prevent smokers from getting lung cancer, found that active smokers taking beta carotene were more likely to get lung cancer. That study had some methodological weaknesses, but most experts recommend against current smokers taking a supplement with beta carotene. That's why I recommend that people with macular degeneration use the AREDS2 formulation, which is appropriate for both smokers and nonsmokers. I would recommend that former smokers use the AREDS2 formulation, based only on minimizing risk.

Please note that foods high in beta carotene are still thought to be helpful in reducing risk for many conditions, including heart disease and several cancers, for smokers and for nonsmokers (but quitting is the best way to reduce cancer risk).
       * * *

Dr. Roach regrets that he is unable to answer individual letters, but will incorporate them in the column whenever possible. Readers may email questions to [email protected] or request an order form of available health newsletters at 628 Virginia Dr., Orlando, FL 32803. Health newsletters may be ordered from www.rbmamall.com.
       (c) 2017 North America Syndicate Inc.
       All Rights Reserved
       
 

Join the Discussion

paNOW is happy to provide a forum for commenting and discussion. Please respect and abide by the house rules: Keep it clean, keep it civil, keep it truthful, stay on topic, be responsible, share your knowledge, and please suggest removal of comments that violate these standards. See full commenting rules.